The Great Infocom Replay: Starcross
Having finished the Zork trilogy, it was time for me to continue on into the great post-Zork canon. I was excited for this, because it means lots of games that I haven’t played yet. First up: Starcross. I was especially excited for Starcross! It’s the first of Infocom’s sci-fi games, and I only remembered hearing good things. I’d meant to get started on the flight to YAPC::Asia, but didn’t manage until I’d begun coming home. On the train to Narita, things got off to a weird start.
First, I realized I needed to consult the game’s manual to get started. I’m not sure if this was done for fun or as copy protection, but fortunately I had a scan of the file I needed. After getting into the meat of the game, it was time to get mapping. Mapping Starcross took a while to get right, but it was fun. The game takes place on a huge space station, a rotating cylinder, in which some of the hallways are endless rings. I liked the idea, but I think that up/down, port/starboard, and fore/aft were used in a pretty confusing way. I’m not sure the map really made sense, but was a nice change of pace without being totally incomprehensible.
The game’s puzzles had a lot going for them. It was clear when there was a puzzle to solve, and it was often clear what had to be done, but not quite how. Some objects had multiple uses, and some puzzles had multiple solutions. Unfortunately, it has a ton of the classic text adventure problems, and they drained the fun from the game at nearly every turn.
The game can silently enter unwinnable state, which you don’t work out until
you can’t solve the next puzzle. (It occurs to me that an interpreter with its
UNDO would be a big help here, since I don’t save enough.)
There are tasks that need to be repeated, despite appearances. Something like this happens:
> SEARCH CONTAINER
You root around but don't find anything.
> SEARCH CONTAINER
You still don't find anything.
> SEARCH CONTAINER
Hey, look, a vital object for solving the game!
[ Your score has gone up 25 points. ]
…and my head explodes.
There are guess-the-verb puzzles, which far too often have as the “right” verb a really strange option. For example, there’s a long-dead spaceman, now just a skeleton in a space suit.
> LOOK IN SUIT
It's a space suit with a dead alien in it.
> SEARCH SKELETON
You don't see anything special.
> EXAMINE SKELETON
It sure is dead.
> TOUCH SKELETON
Something falls out of the sleeve of the suit!
There’s a “thief” character that picks up objects and moves them around. It’s used to good effect (as was the thief in Zork Ⅰ) but it wastes time. Wasting time wouldn’t be a problem, if there wasn’t a part of a time limit built into the game. The time limit can be worked around, but it means you need to play the game in the right order, which might mean going back to an early save once you work that out. (Why is it that I love figuring out the best play order in Suspended, but not anything else?) Even that wouldn’t be so bad, in part because I happily I had started by solving a number of puzzles that can be solved in any order, but there was a problem. Most of the game’s puzzles center around collecting keys, so by the end of the game you’re carrying a bunch of keys, not to mention a few objects key to getting the remaining keys… and there’s an inventory limit. It’s not even a good inventory limit, where the game just says “you can’t carry anything more.” Instead, it’s the kind where, when you’re carrying too much, you start dropping random things.
It did lead to one amusing thing, at least, when I tried to pick up a key and accidentally dropped the space suit I was wearing.
Still, the game is good. I particularly like the representational puzzles, like the solar system and repair room. Its prose is good, but neither as economical as earlier games nor as rich as later ones, making it inferior to both. As in earlier games, I’m frustrated by the number of things mentioned but not examinable. Getting “I don’t know that word [which I just used]” is worse than “you won’t need to refer to that.” I’m hoping that the larger dictionaries of v5 games will allow for better messages like that. I’ve got a good dozen games until I get to those, though.
Next up will be Suspended. I’m not sure how that will go, since I’ve played that game many times every year for the past decade or so. After that, The Witness, about which I know nearly nothing!